Every parent aims to provide only the best for their precious baby to keep them healthy. Since a tiny pumpkin spends a lot of time in a crib, choosing a high-quality baby bed mattress is a top priority. To make a choice easier, we will discuss the core aspects to keep in mind when buying a mattress and review the 15 best baby crib mattresses on the market.
At first glance, selecting the safest and best crib mattress may seem like a challenge: there are far too many parameters to consider. Sizes, weight, types, and materials – all these make a difference.
In order to eliminate some of the burden and make your life easier, we have prepared a list of the main aspects to examine before buying a mattress for your baby. Here they are:
Baby mattresses, as well as ones for adults, can be of two types – foam or innerspring. The foam mattress is usually a more cost-effective option, which is also more lightweight than its competitor. They come in various sizes and thickness, which typically ranges from 3” to 6”.
When choosing the foam mattress, you should go for specially designed models for infants. Moreover, avoid memory foam as the mattress must maintain its shape and remain firm.
Innerspring models are designed differently: steel coils are covered by foam, padding, and fabric. If it’s produced from high-quality materials, it will be rather heavy – definitely heavier than foam mattresses.
It’s advisable to select lower gauge models, as it implies that the wire is thicker; consequently, the mattress is firmer. When buying this type, you should choose mattresses with the following parameters:
Organic materials are non-toxic; therefore, such mattresses are healthier for your baby. Natural materials are numerous. Natural latex, plant-based foam, coconut fibers, wool, and organic cotton are just some of them. To be 100% sure that you are purchasing an organic crib mattress, it must boast the Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certification.
A standard crib mattress size is a minimum of 27.25” x 51.25” inches, according to the CSPC. The thickness must be no more than six inches. However, to make sure that it fits, there must be no gaps larger than two fingers.
It’s advisable to choose models with breathable and waterproof cotton covers. This will make your life easier in terms of washing, and the incidents won’t be a disaster. Also, removable covers are much more convenient.
With babies constantly rolling, a ventilated mattress, which allows airflows to pass, is a must to have. This ensures that the baby is breathing easily, regardless of his/her position.
Double-sided mattresses are convenient as you can use them longer. Their sides differ in the level of firmness, with the firmer one for infants and the softer suiting toddlers.
Based on these factors, we have determined the 15 best baby crib mattresses. All of them are good options that will ensure your pumpkin sleeps safe and sound. However, if we are to determine the top-5, it will be as follows:
|1.||Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed - 100% Breathable||Best Breathable crib mattress||4.9|
|2.||Eco Classica III 2-Stage Baby & Toddler Mattress by Colgate Mattress||Best organic crib mattress||4.8|
|3.||Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattres||Best dual firmness mattress||4.8|
|4.||Big Oshi Oval Baby Bassinet Mattress||Best oval bassinet mattress||4.5|
|5.||Serta SleepTrue 4-Inch Mini Crib Mattress||Best mini mattress||4.7|
* grading scale out of 5 from Amazon at the time of publication
This mattress is literally the best cot mattress among all the offers on the market. It’s easy-to-clean, water-resistant, and breathable. Therefore, your baby will breathe well in any position.
The mattress is a standard size that should fit the majority of cribs. It’s rather firm and can be suitable for infants as well. Another important aspect is the lack of dangerous elements harmful to a tiny baby.
Baby face sleeper meets his match
Our baby makes really bad decisions.
He prefers to sleep on his face. Not head tilted slighty to the left or the right - he sleeps square on his tiny, baby face. We tried moving him - again and again and again and failed miserably each time. We tried explaining that his choices were poor, but that also ended in failure. We tried reasoning, and failed before we started.
I found this through Google at 3am with search terms, "baby face sleeper" or something equally desperate. I bought it immediately, it arrived 2 days later, and it works.
I know my kid will continue to make questionable choices, and I will have to continue to try and find solutions. This is the best solution for our face-sleeper.
We consider this to be the best breathable crib mattress from all the reviewed models. The innovative Breathe-Thru technology, which allows air to flow, totally compensates for the high price. Besides this, it’s convenient and long-lasting – the double-sided feature means that you can choose a firmer or softer side to use.
Sealy baby flex cool 2-stage mattress is a standard crib mattress that adheres to the main principles of a decent model to sleep. It features a soft cotton cover, which is supposed to be PVC-free.
Moreover, the model has sex ever-edge corners to ensure firmness on the sides. The mattress is waterproof and can be cleaned with wipes.
Comfort for our baby
We bought this mattress for our 7mo after returning a memory foam “best seller” infant mattress (it was very hard and he wasn’t sleeping well). This mattress feels airy and bouncy. Because of that feel, it’s comfy enough but still safe. We recommend it!
A good model to choose. It’s likely to fit any standard crib and will serve you for a long time. The mattress is very firm; therefore, even infants are safe to sleep on it. What is really good about it is the easy cleaning. The manufacturer claims that even wet wipes can do the job.
Colgate Mattress produces a non-toxic crib mattress that features organic cotton cover and foam infused with plant oils. The model is certified by CertiPUR and GREENGIARD Gold.
Although the mattress is of standard size, it’s rather lightweight compared to similar models. Despite this, it boasts dual firmness due to a multi-layered design. One side is firmer than the other; therefore, it’s suitable for both infants and toddlers.
Worth the money
I’ve had this mattress for a year now so I can give you an accurate review. My 23 pound one year old always sleeps so great on this mattress. She has jumped, ran, fallen, etc on this mattress and sleeps an average of 15 hours a day. I am happy to say the mattress doesn’t have a sign of wear. It is very light weight and changing the sheet has been so easy!
Eco Classica III is the best organic crib mattress that currently exists on the market. It’s rather firm and long-lasting, which compensates for a rather high price. In general, a good option specifically for those whose babies show the potential for developing an allergy.
A dual-sided mattress has 120 heavy-duty inner coils that ensure good firmness. The product also has a special ortho-insulated layer that ensures additional support for a developing human.
As for the rest, it features pretty basic yet important advantages like a waterproof cover, which is produced from cotton. To ensure quality, the manufacturer offers a 35-year warranty.
Absolutely top quality, love the reversible sides for infant or toddler
We have a business that sells mattresses (unfortunately not crib mattresses yet) and I have seen the quality of crib mattresses that are stocked in major retailers- however we just purchased this mattress for the second time now for our toddler bed because the quality is far superior than those stocked in the big name stores. Absolutely top quality, love the reversible sides for infant or toddler- love it!
The mattress itself is a good choice, especially due to additional support delivered by ortho-insulated layers. However, you may need to buy an extra cover if you want to reap the benefits of a waterproof vinyl cover. Obviously, a baby can’t sleep on vinyl alone.
This mattress from Naturepedic is made from organic materials, including both the filling and the cover. Moreover, the soft cotton cover is waterproof and can be cleaned with some cloth, soap, and water.
The mattress is very firm and has additional support on the edges. It features many certificates from reputable organizations.
Worth the money
Very well made mattress. The mattress is sturdy, but very lightweight. We bought this mattress because it is free of chemicals and flame retardants. We didn’t want out little one having close contact with these chemicals. We will be holding onto this mattress for our second baby.
You should purchase this model from Naturepedic if you are looking for enhanced firmness and organic materials. This model has both. Despite this, it may not be as ventilated as some other models. Also, it’s a bit wider than the standards; therefore, you need to make sure your crib will accommodate it well.
This can be considered a decent infant mattress as its one side is extremely firm. The other one, however, is rather soft and suitable for toddlers. The entire model has a nylon cover.
The mattress is produced of foam. It resists water and odors, which is a serious advantage. What is more, it’s subject to special processing to make it antibacterial.
Worth every penny
I have 3 kids and three of this mattress. It is firm and comfy. Two sides make it work for a long time. No wear down after 3 years of nightly use. Fit is snug with crib and sheets. I'd give it 3- 5 star ratings if I could. My kids sleep well. The matress isn't bouncy so there is no bed for my little monkeys to jump on. Pricey yes. But worthwhile in the long run.
If you are looking for extreme firmness for your infant, this is your choice. Moonlight Slumber produced the best dual firmness mattress, which can be flipped to a softer side and used for a toddler. However, keep in mind that the cover is nylon; therefore, buy an organic cover.
The mini crib mattress size isn’t the only parameter that makes this model stand out. It’s also produced from eco-friendly, recyclable materials, which is a sure benefit for the environment. By the way, this model excludes toxic materials. It’s easy-to-wash due to the removable cover. The cover, in turn, is waterproof and hypoallergenic.
Great for mini crib
I purchased a mini crib with a subpar mattress. This was a great investment for my LO. It’s sturdy, comfortable and fits perfectly. I’m glad we bought it.
A good choice if you are looking for a mini mattress. It’s safe for a baby to sleep and easy-to-clean. The removable cover is a super-useful feature. The only drawback is that the mattress isn’t firm enough. Therefore, you should consult with a pediatrician before buying it for an infant.
Although this isn’t a top-rated baby crib mattress, this model is a good choice for toddlers. It features 150 heavy gauge interwoven coils that are enough to provide a firm surface to sleep. The cover is soft and comfortable. Moreover, it’s hypoallergenic.
The mattress is waterproof from all sides and can be cleaned even with wipes. In order to prove the quality, the manufacturer has subjected the model to the GREENGUARD Gold certification. The model comes with a 10-year warranty.
Great quality, Great Price!
We have a Kolcraft mattress for our 3 year old who still sleeps on it in a toddler bed. He used his from birth until now and it's held up so well. I love that they are wipeable and hypoallergenic. Easy to change the sheets on and lightweight enough they aren't too heavy for a momma to lift and move. We were happy to purchase another for our newest addition. I would recommend this mattress for it's quality and especially for its price!
Although the model isn’t double-sided and can’t be used for newborns, it’s sufficient for toddlers. The coils provide enough firmness. What is more, the waterproof feature is really impressive. A good choice if you are looking for an average mattress at a low price.
The list would be incomplete without an oval-shaped mattress. This mattress is of foam type. It’s rather thick and soft; however, it’s covered with vinyl from both sides. While this isn’t the healthiest choice of material, you can be sure that this model is waterproof. Moreover, it’s easy-to-clean and can be washed in a washing machine.
Received the mattress today! Exactly as described. Fits my Fisher Price Soothing Motion bassinet perfect.
This oval-shaped mattress should be suitable for a standard oval crib. Furthermore, we can call this model an oval bassinet mattress. Keep in mind that this model isn’t the best choice if you are looking for organic materials: the vinyl cover requires an additional layer in order not to harm a baby’s soft skin.
This is a rather firm and decent oval-shaped mattress from Colgate. Its ultimate feature is a larger size. Therefore, it is to be used for an expanded crib. It’s worth noting that this model is rather lightweight. As for the features, the foam mattress has a waterproof backing and non-toxic cover.
As good as I'd hoped
The mattress met all of my expectations: firm, right size, clean and fits sheets. It came quickly and we placed it directly into the bed frame. Good buy!
If you are looking for a large-size oval mattress, this one should be on the list. However, you should be aware that many customers claim it to be very firm and not comfortable. Therefore, you may need to add a softer layer over the mattress.
This breathable crib mattress comes in two colors: white from one side and brown from another. However, both sides are of the same firmness, which is provided by 88 interwoven coils.
The product is safe to use as it boasts certificates from GREENGUARD Gold and JMPA. Moreover, it’s convenient to use. It resists water, odors, mildew, dampness, and mold.
My kid it’s particularly picky on what they sleep on but this if working well compared to the old mattress that came with the bed. Quality feels slightly better than the one that came with the crib.
This mattress is sufficient for toddlers. It fits any standard toddler bed or crib. Besides being safe for the baby’s health, it’s also very convenient to use. The material is odor and water-resistant and easy-to-clean.
The foam mattress from Graco is designed especially for infants. It’s rather firm to provide enough support for a newborn. Besides this, the model has good ventilation: air flows pass through the layers of foam properly.
The product doesn’t contain any toxic materials and is safe to use. The cover is soft and water-resistant. What’s more, it’s removable. The mattress is certified by GREENGUARD Gold.
Great mattress. You won't regret the purchase.
This is such an awesome mattress and at a GREAT PRICE!!! It is worth every penny and feels like a steal. This mattress is a really good size and is very soft and comfortable. It is not waterproof and doesn't come with a cover. I would recommend getting one. My daughter sleeps very well on it. She is usually hot and I haven't had any problems with it being too warm for her.
A decent firm mattress for an infant. It’s rather convenient since the cover is removable and water-resistant: it can be easily washed. The model is very light, although it comes with standard parameters.
Why We Choose It?
The ultimate feature of this mattress is the memory foam that makes sleeping even more comfortable. To enhance the effect, the bamboo cover is very soft and ultra-thin. By the way, it’s waterproof and removable, which makes it an even better choice. It’s vital to note that despite the standard size, the mattress is comparatively lightweight.
We let it air out for half the day, and by bed time it was fully puffed up and had no odor. The princess slept like she has never slept before! I personally don't like memory foam beds, and I thought this was way too firm for her. But as soon as I laid her down to sleep, she was zonked! Came with a price though, as she slept so long and good, she wet the bed LOL! So, that brings me to the next plus. The water proof cover did EXACTLY what it was supposed to do! Took it off, washed it with the sheets, and boom, brand new again. We love this thing!!!
It’s up-to-you to decide whether to buy a memory foam mattress: this one features firm layers beneath a softer one; therefore, it is supposed to keep its shape well. If you purchase it, you will enjoy how easy it is to wash. Moreover, your baby is likely to enjoy a soft cover.
Another model with memory foam offers comfortable sleeping for a baby. The reason is a soft bamboo cover, which is produced from non-slip fabrics. The material is breathable; therefore, it ensures a good airflow. Another advantage is that it’s very lightweight.
Comfortable and Holds its form well
I love this mattress. It is super comfortable even for an adult. It holds its form very well and is therefore safe for an infant. It is not plush in a way that an infant sinks in and this becomes a sleep hazard. My toddler sleeps comfortably in it. She's had a few "accidents" on it but the waterproof cover that comes with the mattress held up well and offered good protection.
A decent choice for a mattress if you want a foam model with a very soft cover. The anti-slip fabric is a pleasant feature. However, the product is produced from some polyurethane foam. Despite this, it has passed CertiPur certification and is considered to be a decent purchase.
This is a mini mattress, which is likely to fit any crib. Besides its size, it stands out with little weight – about four pounds. The compact parameters come together with many other features like water-resistance, hypoallergenic fiber, and lack of toxic elements. An interesting fact is that the fiber core is produced from recycled bottles.
Good quality mattress for mini crib
The mattress fits perfectly on the mini crib. I specifically bought it because it was a thicker mattress than a lot of them so I could be assured that our granddaughter would be able to sleep comfortably on it. She's tried it out once and slept quite well on it. I'm very pleased with this purchase.
The best mini-mattress you will find on the list, as well as on the market. It’s likely to fit the majority of cribs, including portable ones. Besides this, the mattress is easy-to-clean since it features a waterproof vinyl cover. On the contrary, you may need to buy an additional cover as vinyl isn’t organic.
The number of baby crib mattresses is so huge that it’s rather difficult to determine what exact features you need to look for. After all, you should choose the model according to your needs, as well as your baby’s age.
We have gathered all the main parameters that you may encounter while choosing your perfect best crib mattress. They are:
There are three types of mattresses:
The cover is what will touch the soft skin of your precious one. That’s why it’s essential to choose one that is organic. You should prefer materials like cotton. The best idea is to purchase a model made of certified natural materials.
You should avoid models that consist of lead, flame retardants like PBDE, vinyl, polyurethane foam, as well as mercury, and VOCs. Such elements may emit toxic gases, which are harmful to a sensitive growing organism.
Breathable mattresses ensure that your baby receives enough air even when rolling or changing their position to the stomach. Typically, models made of natural materials allow airflows to pass much better. However, if you are looking for enhanced ventilation, buy a mattress with constructed vents on the sides.
Although the majority of mattresses feature at least waterproof covers, there are some that don’t resist water. This is likely to reduce the service time of the mattress: it’s more subject to building mildew or mold due to retained moisture. Moreover, they may retain an unpleasant odor.
A mattress with a removable cover is much more convenient in terms of cleaning, especially if we are speaking about a cover made of organic materials.
At the same time, if your model features, for example, a nylon or vinyl cover, it’s also useful if it can be removed because you can reduce the time your baby is exposed to non-organic materials.
In order to know that the mattress is safe, it’s advisable to look for certified models. Typically, the guarantee of quality is ensured if the model adheres to:
It’s vital to note that certification may apply only to some parts of the mattress (for example, fabrics). Therefore, you should study all the labels properly.
First of all, mattresses come in two main types of sizes: standard and mini. Standard usually fits the majority of standard cribs and toddler beds. According to the standards set by CPSC – the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission – the minimum parameters are 51.25 x 27.25 inches. The thickness should be no more than six inches.
It is not mandatory that the mattress perfectly fits the crib. There can be slight holes. However, they shouldn’t exceed one inch. Otherwise, you risk getting your newborn trapped between the crib borders and the mattress.
Selecting a toxic-free, breathable, and waterproof mattress, made from natural materials isn’t enough. To be sure that your pumpkin is comfortable, you should constantly take care of it. There are several rules to keep the mattress clean:
New mattresses come with a specific scent. In order to get rid of it, air the product out as soon as you buy it. Leave it in a well-ventilated place for at least two days before using it. Moreover, this will help you to eliminate harmful VOCs that can be trapped in the mattress because of the package.
Clean your mattress as soon as any spills occur. They may contain bacteria, as well as harsh chemicals – all of these threaten the well-being of your little one.
Using a pad or cover will help to prolong the life cycle of the mattress. When cleaning, follow the care tips provided by the manufacturer.
Mattresses store dust and dirt that must be removed from time to time. Vacuuming is a good idea since the technique cleans it from the inside. Although this dust is not seen, your baby can breathe it in.
After each cleaning, it’s advisable to disinfect the mattress. This will reduce the risk of exposing the baby to bacteria and chemicals.
Choosing the best cot mattress shouldn’t seem as confusing as it did at the beginning of this article. You just need to determine the key features you’re looking for and select a model from the top-15 baby mattresses on the list.